Examining the Evolution and Components of the Culture of Learning in University Education: A Systematic Scoping Review
Abstract
Introduction: The term "culture of learning" frequently appears in research on educational development and reform, yet defining it precisely remains challenging. Given its varied interpretations across scientific fields, it is crucial to review how authors use "culture of learning" in the context of modern educational environments.
Purpose: The purpose of this study is to comprehensively examine and map the existing literature on the concept of "culture of learning" within educational environments.
Method: The research strategy for this scoping review was structured around the "problem, concept, and context (PCC)" framework to ensure a comprehensive and logical exploration of the literature. This approach facilitated the systematic identification and selection of relevant materials that provide a rationale for each chosen criterion. A detailed research protocol was established prior to initiating the study, outlining the objectives, inclusion criteria, and methodological approach. The reporting of this systematic scoping review adheres to the PRISMA-ScR (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses extension for Scoping Reviews) guidelines, ensuring transparency, rigor, and reproducibility in the review process. This methodology was selected to provide a clear and structured pathway for mapping the existing literature on the culture of learning, highlighting key themes, trends, and gaps within the field.
Results: Upon reviewing 74 articles, we identified and clustered the most frequently occurring terms in the titles, resulting in the formation of five distinct area clusters. These clusters encompass: the effectiveness of teaching and learning processes (and their components); teaching/learning trends; learning styles and processes (and their components); learning model components; and the emphasis on academic literacy as an integral part of the learning culture. Additionally, components of the architecture of the culture of learning were identified: learning environments, learning groups, learning subcultures, learning approaches and methods, and learning values and traditions. This comprehensive analysis allowed to define and structure the components of the learning culture.
Conclusion: This scoping review contributes to the ongoing efforts to understand the concept of the "culture of learning" by providing comprehensive definitions and analyzing its possible components. The results offer educators and policymakers a clearer understanding of what constitutes a culture of learning, enabling them to design and implement more effective educational strategies and policies. These findings can guide the development of curricula that better integrate various learning cultures, thereby enhancing the educational experience for students. By identifying key trends and components of the culture of learning, this review provides a foundation for further research that can explore new methodologies and approaches in education, ultimately leading to improved learning outcomes and more dynamic educational environments.
Downloads
References
Abongdia, J.-F., Galloway, G., & Mammen, J. (2014). An analysis of a sample of South African university students’ reflections on Nelson Mandela as a motivator of learning. Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences, 5(14), 304. https://doi.org/10.5901/mjss.2014.v5n14p304
Albano, G., & Formato, F. (2001). E-learning from expertise: A computational approach to a non-textual culture of learning. In Proceedings IEEE International Conference on Advanced Learning Technologies (pp. 241-242). IEEE. https://doi.org/10.1109/ICALT.2001.943911
Bada, E., Ozkan, Y., & Genc, B. (2012). Culture of learning. In N. M. Seel (Ed.), Encyclopedia of the sciences of learning (pp. 662). Springer.
Balleisen, E. J., Howes, L., & Wibbels, E. (2024). The impact of applied project-based learning on undergraduate student development. Higher Education, 87, 1141–1156.
Berger, E. J., Briody, E. K., Wu, C., Rodríguez-Mejía, F., & Rothstein, R. (2019). Busy times, productive students: Cutoff points marking time in university engineering culture. In Proceedings of the Eighth Research in Engineering Education Symposium (pp. 568-577). REES.
Berger, A. (2000). The meanings of culture: Culture: its many meanings. M/C Journal, 3(2). https://doi.org/10.5204/mcj.1833
Boscart, V. M., d'Avernas, J., Brown, P., & Raasok, M. (2017). Changing the impact of nursing assistants' education in seniors' care: The living classroom in long-term care. Canadian Geriatric Journal, 20(1), 15-21. https://doi.org/10.5770/cgj.20.238
Burkhalter, N. (2013). Overcoming resistance in post-soviet teacher trainees in Kazakhstan. Asian EFL Journal, 15(2), 248-279.
Chowdhury, D., Stolee, P., Sims-Gould, J., & Tong, C. (2023). “Think positive and don’t die alone” - Foreign-born, South Asian older adults’ perceptions on healthy aging. International Journal of Qualitative Studies on Health and Well-Being, 18(1), 1789344.
Creating learning cultures. Assessing the evidence. (2020). CIPD Report. https://www.cipd.org/globalassets/media/knowledge/knowledge-hub/reports/creating-learning-cultures-1_tcm18-75606.pdf
Culver, K. (2023). All in all: Tearing down walls in the scholarship of teaching and learning. Innovative Higher Education, 48, 971–976.
Culver, K., Kezar, A., & Koren, E. R. (2023). Improving access and inclusion for VITAL faculty in the scholarship of teaching and learning through sustained professional development programs. Innovative Higher Education, 48, 1071–1094.
Dammery, G., Ellis, L. A., Churruca, K., Mahadeva, J., Lopez, F., Carrigan, A., Halim, N., Willcock, S., & Braithwaite, J. (2023). The journey to a learning health system in primary care: A qualitative case study utilizing an embedded research approach. BMC Primary Care, 24(1), 22.
Davidoff, J., Fonteneau, E. & Goldstein, J. (2008). Cultural differences in perception: Observations from a remote culture. Journal of Cognition and Culture, 8, 189-209. https://doi.org/10.1163/156853708X358146
Davis, K. A., & Knight, D. B. (2023). Assessing learning processes rather than outcomes: Using critical incidents to explore student learning abroad. Higher Education, 85, 341–357.
Duderstadt, J. J. (1997). The future of the university in an age of knowledge. Online Learning Journal, 1(2).
Durão, M., Nogueira, S., Fernandes, S., & Neves, A. (2023). Entrepreneurship learning: Applying a revised experiential learning model to cultural and creative industries. In A. Mesquita, A. Abreu, J. V. Carvalho, & C. H. P. de Mello (Eds.), Perspectives and trends in education and technology (vol. 320). Springer.
Dziubaniuk, O., Ivanova-Gongne, M., & Nyholm, M. (2023). Learning and teaching sustainable business in the digital era: A connectivism theory approach. International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education, 20.
Ellis, R. A. (2022). Strategic directions in the what and how of learning and teaching innovation—A fifty-year synopsis. Higher Education, 84, 1267–1281.
Findyartini, A., Hawthorne, L., & McColl, G. (2016). How clinical reasoning is taught and learned: Cultural perspectives from the University of Melbourne and Universitas Indonesia. BMC Medical Education, 16, 185.
Glukhov, V., & Vasetskaya, N. (2017). Improving the teaching quality with a smart-education system. In 2017 IEEE VI Forum on Strategic Partnership of Universities and Enterprises of Hi-Tech Branches - Science, Education, Innovations (SPUE) (pp. 17-21). IEEE. https://doi.org/10.1109/IVForum.2017.8245958
Hackett, S., Janssen, J., & Beach, P. (2023). The effectiveness of collaborative online international learning (COIL) on intercultural competence development in higher education. International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education, 20(5).
Heng, K. (2024). Challenges and developments in university research in Cambodia: A case study of two universities. Higher Education, 87, 1593–1613.
Ho, T. T. H., Le, V. H., & Nguyen, D. T. (2023). Effects of career development learning on students’ perceived employability: A longitudinal study. Higher Education, 86, 297–315.
Hora, M. T., & Lee, C. (2024). Does industry experience influence transferable skills instruction? Implications for faculty development and culture theory. Innovative Higher Education.
Ifenthaler, D., Cooper, M., Daniela, L., & Sahin, M. (2023). Social anxiety in digital learning environments: An international perspective and call to action. International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education, 20(50), 1-18.
Issenberg, B., & Scalese, R. (2008). Simulation in health care education. Perspectives in Biology and Medicine, 51, 31-46.
Jin, L., & Cortazzi, M. (2006). Changing practices in Chinese cultures of learning. Language Culture and Curriculum, 19, 5-20. https://doi.org/10.1080/07908310608668751
Jin, L., & Cortazzi, M. (2020). Reaching for the gold standard: Metaphors and good university teachers. Chinese Journal of Applied Linguistics, 43, 131-149. https://doi.org/10.1515/CJAL-2020-0009
Kartal, G., & Balcikanli, C. (2019). Tracking the culture of learning and readiness for learner autonomy in a Turkish context. TEFLIN Journal, 30(1), 22–46.
Kastanakis, M., & Voyer,G.B. (2014).The effect of culture on perception and cognition: A conceptual framework. Journal of Business Research, 67(4), 425-433. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbusres.2013.03.028.
Lejeune, S. M. (2012). Special considerations in the treatment of college students with bipolar disorder. Journal of American College Health, 59(7), 666-669. Erratum in Journal of American College Health, 60(1), 99.
Lewitt, M. S., Cross, B., Sheward, L., & Beirne, P. (2019). Multi-sector perspectives on learning for interprofessional practice: Lessons for higher education and organisational culture. Journal of Interprofessional Care, 33(5), 587-589. https://doi.org/10.1080/13561820.2018.1544548
Li, Y., & Rong, G. (2019). Motivating Chinese undergraduate students to learn EAP: An emancipatory action research study in Shanghai, China. Asian ESP Journal, 15(1).
Liang, Y., Dai, K., & Matthews, K. E. (2024). Followers, customers, or partners? Comparing conceptualisations of students as partners in Australian, Mainland Chinese, and Hong Kong universities. Higher Education.
Lindsell, C. J., Gatto, C. L., Dear, M. L., Buie, R., Rice, T. W., Pulley, J. M., Hartert, T. V., Kripalani, S., Harrell, F. E., Byrne, D. W., Edgeworth, M. C., Steaban, R., Dittus, R. S., & Bernard, G. R. (2021). Learning from what we do, and doing what we learn: A learning health care system in action. Academic Medicine, 96(9), 1291-1299. https://doi.org/10.1097/ACM.0000000000004021
Lipitz-Snyderman, A., Kale, M., Robbins, L., Pfister, D., Fortier, E., Pocus, V., Chimonas, S., & Weingart, S. (2017). Peers without fears? Barriers to effective communication among primary care physicians and oncologists about diagnostic delays in cancer. BMJ Quality & Safety, 26. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjqs-2016-006181
Findyartini, A., Hawthorne, L., & McColl, G. (2016). How clinical reasoning is taught and learned: Cultural perspectives from the University of Melbourne and Universitas Indonesia. BMC Medical Education, 16, 185.
Glukhov, V., & Vasetskaya, N. (2017). Improving the teaching quality with a smart-education system. In 2017 IEEE VI Forum on Strategic Partnership of Universities and Enterprises of Hi-Tech Branches - Science, Education, Innovations (SPUE) (pp. 17-21). IEEE. https://doi.org/10.1109/IVForum.2017.8245958
Hackett, S., Janssen, J., & Beach, P. (2023). The effectiveness of collaborative online international learning (COIL) on intercultural competence development in higher education. International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education, 20(5).
Heng, K. (2024). Challenges and developments in university research in Cambodia: A case study of two universities. Higher Education, 87, 1593–1613.
Ho, T. T. H., Le, V. H., & Nguyen, D. T. (2023). Effects of career development learning on students’ perceived employability: A longitudinal study. Higher Education, 86, 297–315.
Hora, M. T., & Lee, C. (2024). Does industry experience influence transferable skills instruction? Implications for faculty development and culture theory. Innovative Higher Education.
Ifenthaler, D., Cooper, M., Daniela, L., & Sahin, M. (2023). Social anxiety in digital learning environments: An international perspective and call to action. International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education, 20(50), 1-18.
Issenberg, B., & Scalese, R. (2008). Simulation in health care education. Perspectives in Biology and Medicine, 51, 31-46.
Jin, L., & Cortazzi, M. (2006). Changing practices in Chinese cultures of learning. Language Culture and Curriculum, 19, 5-20. https://doi.org/10.1080/07908310608668751
Jin, L., & Cortazzi, M. (2020). Reaching for the gold standard: Metaphors and good university teachers. Chinese Journal of Applied Linguistics, 43, 131-149. https://doi.org/10.1515/CJAL-2020-0009
Kartal, G., & Balcikanli, C. (2019). Tracking the culture of learning and readiness for learner autonomy in a Turkish context. TEFLIN Journal, 30(1), 22–46.
Lejeune, S. M. (2012). Special considerations in the treatment of college students with bipolar disorder. Journal of American College Health, 59(7), 666-669. Erratum in Journal of American College Health, 60(1), 99.
Lewitt, M. S., Cross, B., Sheward, L., & Beirne, P. (2019). Multi-sector perspectives on learning for interprofessional practice: Lessons for higher education and organisational culture. Journal of Interprofessional Care, 33(5), 587-589. https://doi.org/10.1080/13561820.2018.1544548
Li, Y., & Rong, G. (2019). Motivating Chinese undergraduate students to learn EAP: An emancipatory action research study in Shanghai, China. Asian ESP Journal, 15(1).
Liang, Y., Dai, K., & Matthews, K. E. (2024). Followers, customers, or partners? Comparing conceptualisations of students as partners in Australian, Mainland Chinese, and Hong Kong universities. Higher Education.
Lindsell, C. J., Gatto, C. L., Dear, M. L., Buie, R., Rice, T. W., Pulley, J. M., Hartert, T. V., Kripalani, S., Harrell, F. E., Byrne, D. W., Edgeworth, M. C., Steaban, R., Dittus, R. S., & Bernard, G. R. (2021). Learning from what we do, and doing what we learn: A learning health care system in action. Academic Medicine, 96(9), 1291-1299. https://doi.org/10.1097/ACM.0000000000004021
Lipitz-Snyderman, A., Kale, M., Robbins, L., Pfister, D., Fortier, E., Pocus, V., Chimonas, S., & Weingart, S. (2017). Peers without fears? Barriers to effective communication among primary care physicians and oncologists about diagnostic delays in cancer. BMJ Quality & Safety, 26. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjqs-2016-006181
Lixian, J., & Cortazzi, M. (2016). Practising cultures of learning in internationalising universities. Journal of Multilingual and Multicultural Development, 38(3), 237-250.
Madanat, H., Tarawnah, M., & Khzouz, A. (2023). Adapting to the new normal: Asynchronous learning as a promising solution for post-Covid-19 challenges in Jordanian universities - A case study of the American University of Madaba (AUM). In H. M. K. Al Naimiy, M. Bettayeb, H. M. Elmehdi, & I. Shehadi (Eds.), Future trends in education post COVID-19 (pp. 1-19). Springer.
Maior, C., Darău, A. P., Cotoraci, C.-A., & Sasu, A. (2014). Integration of external stakeholders from Alumni Graduates Association into quality assurance in a private university from a former communist country. Quality Assurance in Education, 22(4), 1-10.
Marks, A. (2005). Changing spatial and synchronous structures in the history and culture of learning. Higher Education, 50, 613–630.
McMorland, J., Carroll, B., Copas, S., & Pringle, J. (2003). Enhancing the practice of PhD supervisory relationships through first- and second-person action research/peer partnership inquiry. Forum Qualitative Social Research, 4(2).
Milistetd, M., Salles, W., Backes, A., Isabel, M., & Vieira, J. (2019). Learner-centered teaching in a university-based coach education: First attempts through action research inquiry. International Journal of Sports Science & Coaching, 14, 1-17. https://doi.org/10.1177/1747954119842957
Miller, M., Carroll, D., Jancic, M., & Markworth, K. (2015). Developing a culture of learning around the edTPA: One University’s Journey. The New Educator, 11(1), 37–59.
Morley, S. (2014). Analytic and holistic approaches to Fine Art education: A comparative approach. Journal of Visual Art Practice, 13, 101-113.
Müller, M., Višić, M., & Kovač, M. (2023). Perception and attitudes of students about politically correct speech: A case study from the spectrum of diversity education. Forum for Linguistic Studies, 5(2). https://doi.org/10.59400/fls.v5i2.1723
Mustafa, A., Allouh, M., Mustafeh, I., & Hoja, I. (2013). Anatomy learning styles and strategies among Jordanian and Malaysian medical students: The impact of culture on learning anatomy. Surgical and Radiologic Anatomy: SRA, 35, 1-10. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00276-012-1067-z
Mutale, W., Nzala, S., Martin, M., Rose, E., Heimburger, D., & Goma, F. (2023). Accelerating organizational change to build mentorship culture in Zambian universities. Annals of Global Health, 89, 1-10.
Myllykoski-Laine, S., Postareff, L., Murtonen, M., & Vilppu, H. (2022). Building a framework of a supportive pedagogical culture for teaching and pedagogical development in higher education. Higher Education, 85, 1-17.
O'Connell, J. (2014). A multidisciplinary focus on 21st-century digital learning environments: New program at CSU. In S.-K. Loke (Ed.), Proceedings of the Annual Conference of the Australasian Society for Computers in Learning in Tertiary Education (pp. 201-210). Australasian Society for Computers in Learning in Tertiary Education.
Popov, V., Brinkman, D., Fortuin, K. P. J., Lie, R., & Li, Y. (2022). Challenges home and international students face in group work at a Dutch university. European Journal of Engineering Education, 47(4), 664–678.
Puteh-Behak, F., Darmi, R., & Mohamed, Y. (2015). Implementation of a Western-based multiliteracies pedagogy in Malaysia: A socio-cultural perspective. GEMA Online Journal of Language Studies, 15, 1-24. https://doi.org/10.17576/GEMA-2015-1501-01
Rennie, F., & Robin, M. (2007). The development of distributed learning techniques in Bhutan and Nepal. International Review of Research in Open and Distance Learning, 8(1).
Romeiro, A. E., & Reis, I. W. (2023). Universities as spaces of knowledge creation—going through the test of the pandemic. In A. Mesquita, A. Abreu, J. V. Carvalho, & C. H. P. de Mello (Eds.), Perspectives and trends in education and technology (vol. 320, pp. 1-18). Springer.
Saltmarsh, D., & Saltmarsh, S. (2008). Has anyone read the reading? Using assessment to promote academic literacies and learning cultures. Teaching in Higher Education, 13(6), 621-632.
Senzaki, S., & Masuda, T. (2014). When is perception top-down and when is it not? Culture, narrative, and attention. Cognitive Science, 38(7), 1493-1506.
Sims, S. M., & Lynch, J. W. (2016). Medical educational culture: Introducing patients to applicants as part of the medical school interview: Feasibility and initial impact show and tell. Medical Education Online, 21(1), 31760.
Singh, H., Upadhyay, D. K., & Torretti, D. (2020). Developing health care organizations that pursue learning and exploration of diagnostic excellence: An action plan. Academic Medicine, 95(8), 1172-1178. https://doi.org/10.1097/ACM.0000000000003062
Smith, J., & Brown, A. Building a culture of learning design: Reconsidering the place of online learning in the tertiary curriculum.
Sörensen, I., Volk, S. C., Fürst, S., Vogler, D., & Schäfer, M. S. (2024). “It’s not so easy to measure impact”: A qualitative analysis of how universities measure and evaluate their communication. International Journal of Strategic Communication, 18(2), 93–114.
Strydom, A. H., & Noruwana, J. (1993). Academic standards in South African universities and proposals for quality assurance. Higher Education, 25, 379–393.
Suarez-Balcazar, Y., Harper, G. W., & Lewis, R. (2005). An interactive and contextual model of community-university collaborations for research and action. Health Education & Behavior, 32(1), 84-101.
Tan, W. C. (2023). Doctoral examiners’ narratives of learning to examine in the PhD viva: A call for support. Higher Education, 86, 527–539.
Thomson, C., El-Haram, M., & Emmanuel, R. (2009). Mapping knowledge during sustainability assessment within a PPP school project. In Association of Researchers in Construction Management, ARCOM 2009 - Proceedings of the 25th Annual Conference. ARCOM. https://doi.org/10.1680/udap.2010.163.2.67
Tikhonova, E., Kosycheva, M., & Kasatkin, P. (2023). Exploring academic culture: Unpacking its definition and structure: A systematic scoping review. Journal of Language and Education, 9(4), 151-162.
Tikhonova, E., & Raitskaya, L. (2024). The culture of research: A systematic scoping review. Journal of Language and Education, 10(1), 5-24.
Tomko, M., Newstetter, W., Alemán, M. W., Nagel, R. L., & Linsey, J. (2020). Academic makerspaces as a “design journey”: Developing a learning model for how women students tap into their “toolbox of design.” Artificial Intelligence for Engineering Design, Analysis and Manufacturing, 34(3), 363-373. https://doi.org/10.1017/S089006042000030X
Usunier, M. R., & Squires, V. (2019). Pursuing change in a learning university: The role of the Dean. Journal of Higher Education Theory and Practice, 19(1).
Vu, H., Le, N., Phan, L., & Nguyen, S. (2023). Effectiveness of building a culture of learning among Vietnamese pedagogical university students. International Journal of Education and Practice, 11, 439-449.
Wainwright, E., & Marandet, E. (2010). Parents in higher education: Impacts of university learning on the self and the family. Educational Review, 62(4), 449-465. https://doi.org/10.1080/00131911.2010.487643
Wainwright, E., & Watts, M. (2019). Social mobility in the slipstream: First-generation students’ narratives of university participation and family. Educational Review, 73(1), 111–127.
Winstone, N. E. (2022). Characterising feedback cultures in higher education: An analysis of strategy documents from 134 UK universities. Higher Education, 84, 1107–1125.
Wong, J. T., & Hughes, B. S. (2023). Leveraging learning experience design: Digital media approaches to influence motivational traits that support student learning behaviors in undergraduate online courses. Journal of Computer in Higher Education, 35, 595–632.
Xie, M., King, R. B., & Luo, Y. (2023). Social motivation and deep approaches to learning: A nationwide study among Chinese college students. Higher Education, 85, 669–687.
Xu, S. (2023). Groupwork and collaborative learning: Chinese university students’ struggles and strategies. Higher Education Research & Development, 43, 227-242. https://doi.org/10.1080/07294360.2023.2215174
Yates, L., & Trang Nguyen, T. Q. (2012). Beyond a discourse of deficit: The meaning of silence in the international classroom. International Education Journal: Comparative Perspectives, 11(1), 22-34.
Zou, Y. (2022). Quality of higher education: Organizational and educational perspectives. River Publishers.
Copyright (c) 2024 National Research University Higher School of Economics
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Authors who publish with this journal agree to the Copyright Notice.
